44 Comments

As a lawyer I was, for many years, automatically excused from jury duty, much to my disappointment. That silly legal excuse was eventually eliminated. However, the only jury I have ever gotten to serve on was a Grand Jury. I was originally supposed to report, in downtown Manhattan, on September 11, 2001. As you can imagine, the jury did not convene that afternoon. When we finally did meet, a week or so later, it proved to be a very rewarding experience. Many of the cases we heard involved crimes committed at so-called Ground Zero. Mostly thefts. I felt as if I was helping, in a small way, to putting things right.

Expand full comment

Stefanik is mum, and that is perhaps the only way for her to say the quiet part out loud. She voted "nyet" because that's what the former guy wanted her to do, but wait, he just threw a bone to Mike Johnson. Dear Elise, if I sent a quarter would you buy a clue? The former guys doesn't have anyone along for long, and no matter how you try, your spot under the bus awaits you.

Expand full comment

That would be appropriate justice.

Expand full comment

Is Will Doolittle involved with you, Ken?

Expand full comment

Will writes a Sunday column on this platform - The Front Page.

Expand full comment

Rep. Stefanik does not return calls placed to her by loyal Republican supporters and constituents. I have asked.

Expand full comment

Nor any members of local press.

Expand full comment

Jay Heald was clear. He is well known. He called. No response. I had the same experience twice. The president of our local bank says he does not like her. He’s a loyal Republican.

Expand full comment

Maybe the tide is turning.

Expand full comment

Let’s hope

Expand full comment

It is turning. His odor in court sickens.

Expand full comment

To wit, Jay Elliot Heald is our coroner. Peter Standish Paine II was clear. Valedictorian of his class at Princeton. CEO of Champlain National. These two are Republicans and friends.

Our moribund newspapers do not seem to care.

Substack bleeds reporting. Democracy is threatened when newspapers fail. Yale University historian Timothy Snyder wrote about this in his book On Tyranny. Tim also publishes on Substack.

Expand full comment

Check out my book: The Last American Newspaper. It addresses the importance of local journalism.

Expand full comment

The letter writer should think about 9/11, and expand that to include every state in this country being attacked. One minute you have a home, the next you have a pile of rubble, and you have no where safe to go. You make your way to a local grocery store...........nothing but rubble. How are you going to eat? Neighborhoods are also nothing but rubble. Picture that in America!

Expand full comment

It is unimaginable… but possible.

Expand full comment

Thank you Ken, for pointing out the protracted, daily struggles of too many people on our planet. It is true that many of us in this country cannot imagine hourly strife and disaster...until it hits us, temporarily or individually, smack in the face. It is ironic and very telling that many of the very comfortable (economically) lawmakers in our country, decry helping others less fortunate than themselves both nationally and internationally, and try anything to impede what they call entitlement spending, when they themselves are the entitled. It is also extremely disturbing that so many individuals in our country cannot, will not, see that those lawmakers or corporate executives don't give a hoot for their welfare.

Expand full comment

Every time I hear some pompous arrogant politician cry about all these so-called entitlements "given" to people who HAVE PAID INTO THESE FUNDS ALL THEIR LIVES I have to wonder exactly how entitled THEY are to have a say in where the money goes!

Sorry - that really ticks me off - and believe me I could put it in much coarser language but I doubt its necessary here!!

Expand full comment

I hate to tell you this but we’ve been in a civil war for a long time now. There are multiple sides and multiple fronts but greed is at the center everywhere. Greed both divides us and paradoxically binds us together. It’s the conundrum of consumerism. We are convinced we as individuals are smarter, better, more deserving than others who just want to take from us through taxes so we hate them, but we need to work to buy more stuff, a bigger truck, a drive-thru fast food meal and we can’t get all that without the work of our lesser, lazier neighbors who do not deserve $15/hr flipping burgers but what can we do? We need that burger and the fries too! So we stew and lash out and punch down.

The war is not over for the Rockwell Falls Library, and that it is reopened is not a great victory. Former staff - both women - lost their jobs, were harassed, denigrated, publicly humiliated, and defamed. They are forgotten casualties. And territory of free thought and free expression, of treating others as equals has been lost to the side of top down paternalist morality police.

We are in an uncivil civil war. We are losing.

Expand full comment

Sad points to consider. I suppose the violence is the final act.

Expand full comment

Well, we’ve already been experiencing a fair amount of widespread violence for a while now, just not continuous, although the pending threat of violence has daily reminders all around us. Mike Kibbling pointing a toy gun at a Post Star reporter is on the timeline of the march of war.

The thing with most wars is we end up in them without knowing exactly when or how they started. Almost nobody knows who Adolph Dubs was but his kidnapping and assassination in February of 1979 might be considered the beginning of our wars in Afghanistan, but his death was also a point on the timeline of the Cold War.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adolph_Dubs

Americans feel like the Cold War is over, which is fine with Putin who is not done with war, cold or hot, and we have a lot of Americans serving as Putin’s propaganda machine.

Expand full comment

I witnessed that incident personally and it seems even worse in retrospecdt.

Expand full comment

I live in district 21 and I want to fund and aid urkrain!

Expand full comment

Me too!

Expand full comment

Sedition Stefanik voted No on Ukraine for one reason and one reason only. Make no mistake it was to ingratiate herself with Trump. It’s self interest that drives her actions. Miss Harvard has her eye on being his VP pick.

Expand full comment

Your reader’s comments about stefanik’s vote against funding for Ukraine was way off base! Most every person I know supports Ukraine and hates what Putin is doing to it.

According to everything I have read , most of that money stays in the US and goes to the companies that produce the weapons and ammunition that is then shipped to Ukraine. So by refusing to support it Stefanik is actually working against US companies.

Expand full comment

You are correct about foreign aid spending. Typically about 3/4 of the money spent is with US contractors. Sometimes, depending on the type of aid it can be more. Most people don’t understand that aid is usually an economic stimulus at home.

Expand full comment

It is a movie. But the reality of a possible American civil or revolutionary war is not just that "someone is trying to kill us and we are trying to kill them."

The reality is the rape of American women and girls and the burning of American babies.

Guns and killing people from a distance, or indiscriminate bombings by rockets and planes make war all to impersonal. But war, the ugly truth of war, is the grossly real, insanely horrific inhumanity of it.

Think about that when you talk about a war in America. Think about the rape of American women and girls and the burning of American babies.

Tell me again how you would advocate it. Tell me again how you would support an insurrection led by the likes of Trump and Stefanik. Don't argue that Stefanik would not burn American babies. The forces she would release would do that for her.

I'd like to hear about the pleasure you would take in the horrors of war. Maybe I'm wrong. So convince me.

Expand full comment

It's interesting that Stefanik's congressional neighbor, Claudia Tenney, issued a statement explaining her vote against Ukraine funding. Basically, she wants a plan showing how Ukraine can win before giving any more money to its defense. Morally dubious as that position may be, it's at least a stance. But we don't even get that much from Stefanik.

Expand full comment

Elise Stefanik said that she was against sending $ to Ukraine for "non-lethal" aid - according to an article in the Press Republican.

I wonder if Elise realizes that that "non-lethal" aid includes flak vests, first aid, food...?

Stefanik is a fraud. She is out there now preaching about anti-Semitism, but, let's not forget she has endorsed & fundraised for Paladino who said that "Hitler is the kind of leader we need now".

But, she has seen her campaign coffer$ increase with her "outrage". So she will continue to push the same relentlessly.

Stefanik, unfortunately, will most likely win another two-year term in Congress. Her sixth term, even though she pledged to only serve five.

Stefanik reflects the same as her idol, Donald J. Trump with her con, her quest to remain relevant, to bilk her supporters, to play the game, whatever...she is a fraud. Through & through.

Expand full comment

Can you explain more, including in your column, about what the underlying issues are in this Rockwell Falls situation, who is on which side of the issue, and essentially who has won and with what implications?

Expand full comment

I don't think you can characterize it as winning and losing. Three citizens stepped up to make sure the library reopened and they have accomplished that. The controversy started after the community protested a drag queen story hour at the library. A local minister said the event was sexualizing children. Many turned out at the library lobard meeting.

Two of the three staff members resigned because of threats and the library closed for six months. There was talk about what books were appropriate at the library. Thankfully, there were not book bans.

Expand full comment